14
NovemberRent it out or sell when you move
A common misunderstanding is that you simply decide to leave and the house takes care of itself. That is not true. If you rent the place out, you become a California landlord with real duties whether you live in the next town or across the country. Many Sacramento homeowners move for a new job or a cheaper town and then wonder what to do with the house. The answer depends on your own situation, but the options are basically two: sell it or rent it out or sell when you move it.
If you sell, you walk away clean. No more yard work, no tenant calls at midnight, no property tax bills. But if you have owned the place for a while, the profit might be subject to capital gains tax. The tax rule says you can exclude some of that profit if you have lived in the house for at least two of the past five years. That is the two-out-of-five-years rule. If you have been in the house long enough, selling soon after you move might save you tax money. If you wait too long, you lose that exclusion.
If you rent the place out instead, you become a landlord with California-specific responsibilities. You have to keep the rental in good repair, follow the state's tenant protection laws, and handle security deposits correctly. You cannot just collect rent and ignore problems. If you live far away, you might want to hire a local property manager. They handle repairs, tenant screening, and rent collection for a fee. That fee reduces your monthly profit, but it also saves you the headache of managing from afar.
Taxes work differently for a rental. You can deduct expenses like repairs, insurance, property management fees, and even depreciation. Depreciation lets you deduct a portion of the building's value each year, but when you eventually sell, the IRS wants some of that back as depreciation recapture. That is a tax you pay at a special rate. A CPA or tax professional can explain how this works in your specific case.
Another thing to consider is your mortgage. If you have a low interest rate, selling means giving that up. But if you rent it out, the lender might require a different loan type for investment properties. You should check with your lender before you move.
You also need to think about the local rental market. Sacramento has its own rent control rules and eviction protections. You cannot just raise rent however you like or evict a tenant without cause. The rules change often, so you need to stay current or pay someone who does.
There is no single right answer. Selling gives you cash and freedom. Renting gives you income and a property that might grow in value over time. Talk to a lawyer about landlord liability and to a CPA about taxes. A HUD-approved housing counselor can also help you think through the choice. Take your time and look at your own numbers.
A closer look is at rent it out or sell when you move.
Reviews